Battle - Uvo vs Palm | MangaHelpers



  • Join in and nominate your favorite shows of the summer season 2023!

Battle Uvo vs Palm

Demonspeed

Damegami
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
38,200
Reaction score
46,964
Gender
Male
Country
France
A fight between two Enhancers. It's obviously against CA Palm. Her Hatsu is great and she is more durable thanks to her CA's body. I think she is stronger than Uvo.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
42,776
Reaction score
21,909
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I don't think she would be stronger than uvo to be honest. Uvo was shown to be an intelligent fighter who developed a powerful punch to fight with. On top of that he had a remarkably powerful body. Palm has a very convenient situation as an enhancer so far, her hair allows her to keep a sufficient defense even while using her aura solely to attack however I don't think the amount of raw power she showed does not seem to compare to uvo's. Uvo was able to leave a crater in the ground when punching, the only time we have seen someone exceed such a thing was when yupi went crazy which is quite significant considering how much the manga has advanced when it comes to nen. Not to mention that palm was as far as we know something of a student when it comes to nen, uvo was well past the point where he was being taught nen. Safe for netero uvo is apparently the strongest enhancer we have seen, I can't imagine palm being able to win this one.
 

Phantron

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
795
Gender
Male
Country
United States
I don't think it's ever valid to use the amount of destruction caused by an attack to judge someone's strength because even Meryem only smashes walls prior to being reborn but he is surely physically stronger than any other wall-smashing human we've seen.

Killua can open 5 doors at his home at the end of the Ant arc but Palm is still physically stronger, so she has immense strength. At the Ant arc, Killua can pretty much kill fodder Ants without breaking a sweat just using his yoyo while the Spiders have to use considerable effort to do the same, so Palm will likely wipe the floor with Ubogin. Of course overall the power level is pretty much out of control by the time the Ant arc goes around.
 

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
42,776
Reaction score
21,909
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
We don't know if palm is physically stronger. She is an enhancer and overall more experienced with aura than killua, both of those things could easily account for the difference we saw a while back. Killua was in a bad position against the full might of palm's offense but I doubt killua would just be in a bad position against uvo. In a similar scenario I can't imagine killua even holding his ground against uvo at all. As powerful as the yo yo can be I sincerely doubt they would hold a candle to a missile.
 

Phantron

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
795
Gender
Male
Country
United States
Because there are no power level readings in HXH you're stuck with the usual stuff like 'block bullets' 'block rocket launchers' to describe how strong someone is. When Meryem was first born he smashed a wall with his tail and the Royal Guard commented on his strength, even though this is something Gon and Killua can do way back in Yorknew. Does this mean Meryem was only as strong as Gon in the Yorknew arc? Of course not. Likewise 'block missile' is just a standard to show a general level of defense. As we'd later find out even aura-enhanced bullets (Ikalgo) can pierce the defense of an Chimera Ant, whose base physical strength far exceeds any human. In the world of HXH, adding aura to any weapon is literally pixie dust and it also works in reverse, namely anything without aura for some reason does no appreciable damage, even though it's hard to imagine adding pixie dust to a bullet somehow makes it stronger than a rocket launcher.

The Spiders are basically comparable to a strong criiminal organization. Kuroro had to fake his death to get the Mafia off his back and hire Ilumi to deal with the leaders. So while Spiders are a strong organization they're not even capable of having an extended war with the Mafia. The Ants under Meryem are strong enough to function as a nation and will shortly be ready to attack the entire world. There's no way a criminal organization is comparable to a nation, and thus the guys you pick to fight a nation level power must be way stronger than the guys you'd take to fight a criminal organization. While I'd argue Killua, Gon, and Palm have no business participating in the Ant arc, the fact is that they're considered as guys capable of fighting a nation level power by the end of that arc even in their normal state, which is way out of the league of Ubogin, who is still just a member of a criminal organization. If you're doubting Killua or Palm could beat Ubogin, who is a strong fighter from a criminal organization, why on earth would Netero believe these guys are of any help fighting an enemy that could destroy the entire world? It's true Palm was originally just there for her special ability, but after she got out of the cocoon she's clearly stronger than Killua in terms of raw power.

I don't like to compare characters in the Ant arc to characters before it, because characters in the Ant arc must absolutely wipe the floor against characters outside it, or otherwise the conclusion you get is that Netero was a fool to bring a bunch of scrubs while the fate of the world is at stake, or that having nukes solve all your problem so you can bring all the scrubs you want.
 

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
If this thread goes on for too long, then it will be the biggest insult to the Spiders.

Uvogin will obviously wipe the floor with Palm with TREMENDOUS ease. Uvogin is someone who mastered Enhancement to 100%. Kurapika's teacher personally stated that it's difficult to master your category to 100%, extremely difficult. And Uvo if I'm not mistaken was said to have went even beyond that measure. And here, people are saying that Palm would defeat him.

Killua can open 5 doors at his home at the end of the Ant arc but Palm is still physically stronger, so she has immense strength. At the Ant arc, Killua can pretty much kill fodder Ants without breaking a sweat just using his yoyo while the Spiders have to use considerable effort to do the same, so Palm will likely wipe the floor with Ubogin. Of course overall the power level is pretty much out of control by the time the Ant arc goes around.
What considerable effort ? Using their Hatsu is a considerable effort ? It's the exact same as Killua using his yo yo. Also, have you forgot Killua ended up almost dead facing against some of the weakest ants and division commanders ? While the Spiders were absolutely chill by the end of it.

The Spiders are basically comparable to a strong criiminal organization. Kuroro had to fake his death to get the Mafia off his back and hire Ilumi to deal with the leaders. So while Spiders are a strong organization they're not even capable of having an extended war with the Mafia. The Ants under Meryem are strong enough to function as a nation and will shortly be ready to attack the entire world. There's no way a criminal organization is comparable to a nation, and thus the guys you pick to fight a nation level power must be way stronger than the guys you'd take to fight a criminal organization. While I'd argue Killua, Gon, and Palm have no business participating in the Ant arc, the fact is that they're considered as guys capable of fighting a nation level power by the end of that arc even in their normal state, which is way out of the league of Ubogin, who is still just a member of a criminal organization. If you're doubting Killua or Palm could beat Ubogin, who is a strong fighter from a criminal organization, why on earth would Netero believe these guys are of any help fighting an enemy that could destroy the entire world? It's true Palm was originally just there for her special ability, but after she got out of the cocoon she's clearly stronger than Killua in terms of raw power.
This is honestly your argument ? Knuckle also stated that an army can stop and defeat the ants, so how does that make them different from the Spiders who wiped out over 2000 mafia members with ease and went on a war with an entire city? Are you saying the members of the Chimera ants Extermination team can fight against 2000 armed men ? Take into consideration that Genthru (who is stronger than most of the CE team) and his boys could have easily been defeated by a bunch of armed men (likely less than 20) who can't even use Nen. So not every Nen user can defeat an army of armed men, even if they can't use Nen. And Chrollo was never afraid of the Mafia, he told Uvogin that he is willing to wage a war against the mafia around the world, to which Uvogin answered with sheer excitement. He only faked his death to spare himself the nuisance.

I don't like to compare characters in the Ant arc to characters before it, because characters in the Ant arc must absolutely wipe the floor against characters outside it, or otherwise the conclusion you get is that Netero was a fool to bring a bunch of scrubs while the fate of the world is at stake, or that having nukes solve all your problem so you can bring all the scrubs you want.
So what are you saying ? That Knov and Morel are much stronger than all of the Zodiac and are the two strongest hunters in the world ? Netero had no possible way of knowing how strong the Ants are, neither did Knov or Morel. Netero made the wrong choice, his boys were absolutely no Match for the ants. They required two traitorous ant to help them (Meleoron and Ikalgo), and it's only thanks to those two ants, the CE team survived that long. And even with these ants help, they were utmost pathetic and helpless against the Royal family. So yes, the nuke was his only bet, especially considering that he told Meruem that his men are weak and may have already been slaughtered by his Royal Guards. He only wanted them to distract the RG so that he may fight the King, he never thought or even considered they stood a chance against the Chimera Ants. Also, outside the Royal family, the other Chimera ants are but common trash. This is proved as even Cheetu who gave Morel trouble was pathetically one shotted by Silva who had trouble against Chrollo even with Zeno at his back. That just shows where the Extermination team stands compared to the spiders. And one last thing, Killua who slaughtered a whole squad was still nothing but a joke against Illumi, who is likely weaker than Hisoka, and Hisoka is just another Phantom Troupe member.
 
Last edited:

Phantron

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
795
Gender
Male
Country
United States
There's a huge difference between 'guys with big guns' and a professional army. Unfortunately HXH did a very poor job trying to convey the said difference. A professional army is supposed to wipe the floor with aura users, which is why when the team of the world's most capable Hunters failed to stop Meryem, Knuckle's solution was to get a professional army. Of course you would never be able to tell that based on the story. Although there's this fascination with Mafia being powerful, they're not even professional murderers, like they said themselves. The mercenaries hired to guard the GI games are likely significantly stronger, and a professional army stronger still.
 

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
"Professional army" is still composed of ordinary men with guns. Maybe skilled, war veterans, but no Nen users. Against a man like Uvogin, no matter how professional you're, you're still just another ant to squash beneath his steel hard foot. Mafia aren't professionals, but they aren't kiddos, they know their trade very well. Of course, this is all me taking your concept of "professional army" into consideration, even though this manga has nothing like this whatsoever. What the story in HxH is trying to tell is, no matter how strong you're, you're still one man. Togashi is trying to make this manga close to reality, that's why, he isn't making Nen users invincible. The army Knuckle spoke of is just another army of "guys with big guns." Only difference is, A LOT of guys with A LOT of big guns. Even if you're a Nen user, you aren't immune to guns and knives.
 

Phantron

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
795
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The American army is widely believed to be able to fight the rest of the world's combined military might and still win in a conventional warfare. The American militia would have a hard time defeating the Canadian army if Canada invaded. It's pretty convenient that the world of HXH does not have helicopters because if helicopters exist in the world of HXH, you'd pretty much only need one heiocopter to take down any aura user because there's no way aura techniques can hit a helicopter in a standoff distance (if they can people should be able to fight each other via very long distances like Dragonball) and it's just a matter of time before you get gunned down. NRA enthuaists are probably more skilled with firearms than the Mafia. Whether in the world of HXH or real life, the point is not that the Mafia can even hold off a police force with some special teams let alone an army. It's that Mafia has connections to the government so they don't have to worry about fighting even a militia level entity (e.g. the police + SWAT team) because they will definitely lose.

Of course I realize Killua also said he can stop tanks and fighter jets, which is actually quite absurd when you think about it. If he can stop fighter jets that means he must be able to throw projectiles a distance of perhaps in the kilometer range and still retain their full power. Perhaps what makes HXH especially worse is that at some level it tries to acknowledge the fact that military might is far superior to superpowers, except it totally failed to make it some convincing. Compared to most shonen that just always assumed military might is irrelevent implicitly.

If it is so hard to defeat aura users, the world would be ruled by aura users by now. In particular the Hunter's Association, which is clearly the strongest organization when it comes to a group of aura users, would have no reason to need to take orders from anyone, and yet Netero said the Hunter's Association will take the responsibility for all the dirty work needed to defeat Meryem, which means they're still subservient to a nation-level entity (most liklely the equivalent of UN). That is, if someone caught the detail that a Rose was used, you can bet it's the Hunter's Association that will take the fall out, not whoever actually supplied the said weapon to Netero.

---------- Post added at 01:51 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:22 AM ----------

HXH gets into trouble because it's more complicated than the average shonen but whether it's due to ability or just plain laziness it is rarely able to make coherence of its grand plots. If you assume the entire content of HXH so far is actually planned as opposed to just Togashi making stuff as he goes, then we know that the Ants are a invading species from the outside world. After all, if Ging, who can't even get a license to go to the Dark Continent knows that the Ants are from there, surely the true powers of HXH world knows about this too and they'd understand that an invading species from the Dark Continent would certainly challenge the survival of human race (that's why contact with Dark Continent is forbidden in the first place).

Therefore there should be none of this political fake stuff about inability to send an army. What should have happened is you'd have the most powerful army of the world attack the capital head on prior to the gathering of the entire nation's population. This army would defeat the Royal Guard's puppets relatively easily (after all the Royal Guards are attempting to create a stronger army so their puppets clearly aren't capable fighting a national level entity) followed by a huge war of attrition between Meryem and his Royal Guards against a massive army. The strike team would be the ones who will pursue Meryem after he and the Royal Guards have been weakened by conventional firepower. In fact, given the Hunters know about the Ants ability to absorb aura users into their own ranks, it makes all the more sense to use conventional firepower since if Meryem blows up a tank it's not like the Ants get an extra tank to use, but if Meryem manages to capture a powerful aura user you might be looking at another opponent. Meryem's ability to consume aura would be absolutely devastating against a team of aura users (which is probably why he never used it on any opponent) but would be pretty much useless against an army consist of normal humans. While this cleanup duty isn't glamorous, it is also vital because Meryem absolutely will be able to escape against an army due to his superior physical abilities. If HXH is supposed to be the 'realistic' then you'd have Meryem and the Royal Guards finally fight the Hunters after they've been fighting continously for days if not weeks and already severely weakened.

But of course even though Togashi likes to throw some curveball plot, this is probably too curveball in terms of shonen, even though you're talking about a nation versus nation fight (the Ants fully expect to conquer the world with the personnel they have, so they can be considered as strong as a nation) where even the strongest indivduals have no business of participating in during the initial phase, let alone newbies like Gon. But the price to make the story more shonen like is that the power level gets completely out of whack, as now we've debates on whether guys who just successfully fended off a human extinction level event compared to a powerful criminal organization.
 
Last edited:

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
42,776
Reaction score
21,909
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
The whole thing would at large depend on the aura users involved though. Its not like high level aura users are common in the HH world. Looking at hisoka's ratings even among the zodiacs it does not seem like many would be a match for alumi (although many things would come into play). So based on what we have seen I would make the point that nen users capable of taking on an army would be relatively rare. Most nen users would naturally fall in the low level category. Then you have those comparable to gon and killua who should be around mid level nen users and should be rarer and then you have the high level ones which should be extremely rare.

There is also the consideration that we have no idea of just what an HH army implies. The technology is unknown to us altogether. Just look at the rose. Its readily available technology which allowed the production of a cheap weapon of mass destruction. Millions were produced at a time and that was apparently a long time ago. Then you have a couple of extraordinary weapons which are capable of harming nen users (like the knife kuroro had) and such. And of course then you are dealing with any potential nen users they might have, their numbers and tactics. There are too many unknowns when it comes to armies here.
 

Phantron

Registered User
有名人 / Yuumeijin / Celebrity
Joined
Sep 2, 2011
Messages
2,698
Reaction score
795
Gender
Male
Country
United States
The problem with HXH is that there are no power levels but it'd really be useful to have some idea of say what each character's total AP. In HXH we have both unreliable overall measurement of power (e.g. Meryem displays power by smashing walls, which is the same as Gon in Yorknew) and that for the most part many characters are unrelible narrators, like Killua saying he can defeat jets (an absurdity when he cannot attack a Dragonfly Ant in the air, as jets attack from far higher distances). Hisoka is another example as he thinks he's the strongest man in the world so all his evaluation are biased with himself being the strongest without any real reason to believe so and it's also biased by his personal preferences.

So far as technology goes, they have tanks and they have fighter jets in the world of HXH. If a special knife can harm an aura user then you'd think military grade weapons ought to be able to hurt an aura user very easily, because it's not like the knife was constructed by some exotic material or technology. If it's just a quality of the item, it's hard to imagine most guns somehow have less penetrating power than the best made knives. Even if it's something like the knife is aura-coated as a function of the weapon's maker (which can't be everything there is because obviously any weapon used by an aura user is aura-coated by its user but not every random weapon used by an aura user could harm Silva) then it's just a matter of getting someone to infuse aura into all your ammunition. Of course in that scenario it'd be pretty silly too since that'd mean if they had some aura-infused sniper rounds Ubogin might've died in a single shot in the head.

Overall I'd say the reason why aura users appear strong is because their existence is relatively unknown so your average guy isn't aware of the tactics required to defeat them. But at the army level certainly they will have someone who knows how to deal with these guys, otherwise there's no way the world of HXH can even function as all the head of state ought to be aura users just because otherwise you'd have already been killed by one.

Again I'd like to point out that there's probably a reason why helicopters don't exist in HXH, because if they do it'd make the whole notion of aura user able to fight an army a joke. We know aura users are not capable of hitting aerial targets in a standoff distance with just aura alone, because if they can have an attack that does significant damage from that far away, they'd fight like Dragonball and just lob aura blasts at enemies barely in visual range. A helicopter can easily track an aura user's movement (they're slower than cars over any reasonable distance, which is why Spiders drive cars to chase down Kurapika) and I don't see how a 30mm chain gun can possibly do less damage than some special knife Kuroro managed to buy. Unless an aura user picks up a Stinger or whatever, there's virtually no way they can deal with a single helicopter piloted by someone who knows what he's dealing with, so an aura user is strictly weaker than a vehicle specialized for anti-ground warfare. Sure helicopters conveniently don't seem to exist in HXH, but that puts a rather low upper bound on what an aura user can do against an army.
 
Last edited:

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
@Phantron

I'm not exactly sure what's the point of all that post. You deviated almost completely from the main topic. Please, try to stay on topic and make your post as short and as simple as possible so it doesn't become to difficult too reply to you.

This thread is about Uvo and Palm. And for better arguments, we started to compare the Phantom Troupe to the CEA team. So let's try to stay on that. So far, every single manga evidence, clearly puts the PT way above the CAE team.
 
Last edited:

Demonspeed

Damegami
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
38,200
Reaction score
46,964
Gender
Male
Country
France
I don't really see how Uvo could beat Palm to be honest. Other than her CA body which is even more resistant thanks to her Nen category and her armor she has Wink Blue. It means Uvo won't be able to attack her by surprise. BBI can probably damage her, but Uvo can't one-shot her. Palm has strength, durability and can see Uvo perform all his attacks, BBI is powerful put it's just a straight punch.
 

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
Likewise, I can't imagine Uvo losing. Palm is a considerably weak Enhancer. I'm serious, as she couldn't deal any significant damage to Killua even with Ko, which is the strongest basic form of attack, especially for Enhancers. So if even with Ko she couldn't damage Killua, then the chances of her scratching Uvo are 30% at best. Maybe I'm exaggerating, but you get the point.

So Palm only has durability with no strength. BBI is a straight punch indeed. A straight punch that has a power to literally vaporize the ground on a huge scale. For an Enhancer, a straight punch is all that is needed to kill anyone. Even Gon's Rock, which is the exact same as Uvo's BBI (but several levels weaker), was shown to take out anyone that takes it directly. Unless they are a high level Enhancers of their own. But seeing the minuscule damage Palm causes with a Ko, then she's definitely not a high level Enhancer.
 
Last edited:

kkck

Waifu Slayer
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Joined
Sep 3, 2007
Messages
42,776
Reaction score
21,909
Gender
Hidden
Country
Fire Nation
I don't really see how Uvo could beat Palm to be honest. Other than her CA body which is even more resistant thanks to her Nen category and her armor she has Wink Blue. It means Uvo won't be able to attack her by surprise. BBI can probably damage her, but Uvo can't one-shot her. Palm has strength, durability and can see Uvo perform all his attacks, BBI is powerful put it's just a straight punch.
As far as fighting goes all palm has is pretty much a straight punch too though. Her hair armor does not really enhance offense, it enhances defense. And overall I agree, palm's attacks did not even significantly harm killua. Uvo is most likely physically superior to killua even today and has an enormously powerful nen. If killua takes a big bang impact he would get obliterated, it wouldn't be a situation of him being at a disadvantage. Uvo was incredibly power and on top of that he actually was a smart fighter.
 

mousiehamster

Registered User
上級員 / Jyoukuuin / Sr. Member
Joined
Apr 11, 2012
Messages
327
Reaction score
165
Gender
Male
Country
Hong Kong
So far as technology goes, they have tanks and they have fighter jets in the world of HXH. If a special knife can harm an aura user then you'd think military grade weapons ought to be able to hurt an aura user very easily, because it's not like the knife was constructed by some exotic material or technology. If it's just a quality of the item, it's hard to imagine most guns somehow have less penetrating power than the best made knives. Even if it's something like the knife is aura-coated as a function of the weapon's maker (which can't be everything there is because obviously any weapon used by an aura user is aura-coated by its user but not every random weapon used by an aura user could harm Silva) then it's just a matter of getting someone to infuse aura into all your ammunition. Of course in that scenario it'd be pretty silly too since that'd mean if they had some aura-infused sniper rounds Ubogin might've died in a single shot in the head.
Kuroro poured his nen into the knife, presumably. I'm guessing that even weapons that are enhanced have a breaking point, and its breaking point is dependent on the material/expertise of construction. No idea what trick the maker of the benz knife employed, but it should be assumed that the knife is not some kind of run of the mill weapon, and certainly not equivalent to some run of the mill firearm.

Overall I'd say the reason why aura users appear strong is because their existence is relatively unknown so your average guy isn't aware of the tactics required to defeat them. But at the army level certainly they will have someone who knows how to deal with these guys, otherwise there's no way the world of HXH can even function as all the head of state ought to be aura users just because otherwise you'd have already been killed by one.
Who knows whether these guys use nen or not? It was shown early in the manga that some politicians subconsciously use nen. And of course nen users who specialize in combat may of course willingly make themselves subservient to those who serve a greater purpose.

Again I'd like to point out that there's probably a reason why helicopters don't exist in HXH, because if they do it'd make the whole notion of aura user able to fight an army a joke. We know aura users are not capable of hitting aerial targets in a standoff distance with just aura alone, because if they can have an attack that does significant damage from that far away, they'd fight like Dragonball and just lob aura blasts at enemies barely in visual range. A helicopter can easily track an aura user's movement (they're slower than cars over any reasonable distance, which is why Spiders drive cars to chase down Kurapika) and I don't see how a 30mm chain gun can possibly do less damage than some special knife Kuroro managed to buy. Unless an aura user picks up a Stinger or whatever, there's virtually no way they can deal with a single helicopter piloted by someone who knows what he's dealing with, so an aura user is strictly weaker than a vehicle specialized for anti-ground warfare. Sure helicopters conveniently don't seem to exist in HXH, but that puts a rather low upper bound on what an aura user can do against an army.
Didn't Franklin gun down dozens of helicopters?

Helicopters and jets are great but let's face it, they're fragile. They must remain airborne for a reasonable amount of time which means the least possible amount of weight on the frame. I also have no doubt that nen users could easily hijack their own helicopter and fight enemy helicopters on a similar plane. Hisoka could probably reroute rockets with bungee gum and franklin could probably shoot them down.

An army has the edge on nen users in only one respect: area of effect damage. Missiles and rockets fired indiscriminately to a general area will probably deal significant damage to nen users. But i would certainly not imagine the rank and file military grunt with their puny assault rifles, machine guns and even rocket launchers to pose much of a threat. Basically you would need heavy armor in large numbers, at a great distance, to stand a chance against high level nen users. On the other hand, guys like Squalla and that Nostrade head bodyguard would of course get gunned down quick.
 

tupadre97

Registered User
中級員 / Chuukyuuin / Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2013
Messages
158
Reaction score
32
Age
29
Gender
Male
Country
Marine Headquarters
Imo the fight can go either way but i'm leaning more towards Palm cuz she's a chimera ant.
There's a huge difference between 'guys with big guns' and a professional army. Unfortunately HXH did a very poor job trying to convey the said difference. A professional army is supposed to wipe the floor with aura users, which is why when the team of the world's most capable Hunters failed to stop Meryem, Knuckle's solution was to get a professional army. Of course you would never be able to tell that based on the story. Although there's this fascination with Mafia being powerful, they're not even professional murderers, like they said themselves. The mercenaries hired to guard the GI games are likely significantly stronger, and a professional army stronger still.
Who the hell told you that? Maybe they'd beat weak nen users but they aren't doing shit to any experienced nen users unless they come with chemical weapons, air strikes, roses, and some amazing strategy. Otherwise they'd get demolished.

---------- Post added at 01:29 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:15 AM ----------

The American army is widely believed to be able to fight the rest of the world's combined military might and still win in a conventional warfare. The American militia would have a hard time defeating the Canadian army if Canada invaded. It's pretty convenient that the world of HXH does not have helicopters because if helicopters exist in the world of HXH, you'd pretty much only need one heiocopter to take down any aura user because there's no way aura techniques can hit a helicopter in a standoff distance (if they can people should be able to fight each other via very long distances like Dragonball) and it's just a matter of time before you get gunned down. NRA enthuaists are probably more skilled with firearms than the Mafia. Whether in the world of HXH or real life, the point is not that the Mafia can even hold off a police force with some special teams let alone an army. It's that Mafia has connections to the government so they don't have to worry about fighting even a militia level entity (e.g. the police + SWAT team) because they will definitely lose.

Of course I realize Killua also said he can stop tanks and fighter jets, which is actually quite absurd when you think about it. If he can stop fighter jets that means he must be able to throw projectiles a distance of perhaps in the kilometer range and still retain their full power. Perhaps what makes HXH especially worse is that at some level it tries to acknowledge the fact that military might is far superior to superpowers, except it totally failed to make it some convincing. Compared to most shonen that just always assumed military might is irrelevent implicitly.

If it is so hard to defeat aura users, the world would be ruled by aura users by now. In particular the Hunter's Association, which is clearly the strongest organization when it comes to a group of aura users, would have no reason to need to take orders from anyone, and yet Netero said the Hunter's Association will take the responsibility for all the dirty work needed to defeat Meryem, which means they're still subservient to a nation-level entity (most liklely the equivalent of UN). That is, if someone caught the detail that a Rose was used, you can bet it's the Hunter's Association that will take the fall out, not whoever actually supplied the said weapon to Netero.
Are you serious? First off idk why u don't think the HxH world doesn't have helicopters just bcuz togashi hasn't drawn any. Second off idk why u think a helicopter can kill a hypersonic nen user, thats one of the most completely absurd things i've ever heard. Also why is it absurd that killua can destroy fighter jets when you know he uses LIGHTNING and can move and react at the speed of lightning. I can see what ur saying that if nen users are so powerful why haven't they taken over the world but your forgetting all the tools a modern military has at their disposal (u know like chemical weapons, biological weapons, napalm air strikes, white phospherous shells, moabs if they exist in hxh, and those nukes called roses. Hell u can pretty much kill even the strongest nen user with a rose evidenced by what happened to meruem). U also forget other nen users can also fight each other and government can send their own nen users to kill them or just hire someone from the association. I can still see what ur saying that they could have taken over b4 all this technology but we don't know how adept ppl were with nen back then. For all we know no one had created until a system for identifying, categorizing, and training nen until very recently to the timeline of the manga (like 100 years ago for something). B4 then maybe ppl who unlocked nen didn't even no they could make hatsu or make a proper one, or put conditions on them. The hunter association is probably a recently made organization too after nen became streamlined now that ppl had a proper system to learn it under.

---------- Post added at 01:32 AM ---------- Previous post was at 01:29 AM ----------

In HXH we have both unreliable overall measurement of power (e.g. Meryem displays power by smashing walls, which is the same as Gon in Yorknew)
Are u serious dude? Did you miss the part where he easily one shot multiple chimera ants and nen users with durability higher than wall level? Or when he EASILY ripped off Netero limbs where as Netero is a character with some of the strongest nen and durability in the series or did you just miss that? Going off his huge amount of nen and power alone he is casually multi-city block level.
 

EverEndingStory

Registered User
下級員 / Kakyuuin / Jr. Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2012
Messages
72
Reaction score
47
Gender
Hidden
Country
United States
So while Spiders are a strong organization they're not even capable of having an extended war with the Mafia.
Uvogin single handedly took out half of the Shadow Beasts, the "muscle" of the Mafia - they are more then capable of waging war. Zeno told the mafia brass that, even if he were to give them all back their weapons, he could still kill them all in 7 seconds. And he, tag-teaming with Silva (who is the head of Zoldyck family, and thus at least on par with Zeno), was unable to kill Chrollo when Chrollo wasn't even blood-lusted. So you're dead wrong there.

At the Ant arc, Killua can pretty much kill fodder Ants without breaking a sweat just using his yoyo while the Spiders have to use considerable effort to do the same.
Gon and Killua only ever get into one v. one confrontations with Soldier and Officer level Chimera Ants - they never go into direct one v. one with Squadron Leaders or Royals.
The only Troupe member shown using any kind of "considerable effort" (and I use that term lightly) is Feitan, who is going up against a Squadron Leader.
Morel and Knuckle (who are, as you say, "considered as guys capable of fighting a nation level power") are shown going up against Squadron Leaders, and exhausting way more effort than Feitan did going up against his.
And to top it all off: one of those Squadron Leaders whom Knuckle and Morel faught against (and, get this, couldn't even manage to kill) was later taken out with one blow by Silva, the same man who was on par with the leader of the Troupe ONLY AFTER TEAMING UP WITH HIS FATHER.

And I rest my case.
 

Demonspeed

Damegami
神のごとし / Kami no Gotoshi / Godlike
Global Moderator
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
38,200
Reaction score
46,964
Gender
Male
Country
France
About the knives, they have been made by Benny Delon, who was a genius. So, not only the material is good but the knives contain his aura. If Chrollo adds his aura the knife is even more powerful. It's true that nen is complex HXH is still about power levels. Your abilities help but it will be very difficult to beat someone who has a stronger aura and masters the basis, this is the basic firepower used by all the Nen users. They can be hurt by weapons but if you don't use Shu it won't be very effective. Uvo has been hurt by Bazooka but it can't kill him. You can easily destroy things like iron with Nen and you can even kill an human with a single hit. Killua, who is a novice has been able to beat an army alone. It's not that the weapons can hurt him a little but he has the firepower( his basic nen skills + his electricity). During the Hunter exam he beaten his rivals rapidly, he can do the same to any normal army. Even if they launch a missile at him he can easily dodge it, or destroy it and I don't think normal guns would hurt him if he uses Ten. It's almost impossible for normal armies to beat them.
 

KingOfNight

Registered User
英雄メンバー / Eiyuu Menbaa / Hero Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2012
Messages
2,314
Reaction score
694
Gender
Male
Country
Fire Nation
Uvo has been hurt by Bazooka but it can't kill him. You can easily destroy things like iron with Nen and you can even kill an human with a single hit. Killua, who is a novice has been able to beat an army alone. It's not that the weapons can hurt him a little but he has the firepower( his basic nen skills + his electricity). During the Hunter exam he beaten his rivals rapidly, he can do the same to any normal army. Even if they launch a missile at him he can easily dodge it, or destroy it and I don't think normal guns would hurt him if he uses Ten. It's almost impossible for normal armies to beat them.
What army? In the hunter exam? Killua could do it, because he can do it with or without Nen. You can't compare those guys to armed - to the teeth - men. Again, a normal army with a lazy ass commander would have been capable of killing Genthru and his boys, and they were far above Killua (at least, Genthru was). Sub, a first-class Nen user got taken out by a yo yo, and he has a higher Nen volume the Killua. A yo yo is obviously and ridiculously inferior to a Bazooka so...yeah. Killua taking an armed army isn't happening.
 
Top