Anyone watched Birth 2004?
I just watched it and i kinda like it, not very much tho I don’t like open endings where it leaves the viewers uncertain. I read some discussions and people have very different takes on it.
It is a romance movie, About a widow trying to find love after her husband died. After 10 years she finally accepted to let go of her old love but a kid appeared in her life and claimed to be her dead husband and he knew very detailed information about her and her family. She tried to resist at first but eventually she give in but the kid told her that he was lying all along and she returned back to her senses and she fixed her relationship with the new guy.
The controversy about whether the kid was lying or not. It turned out that the kid found love letters by the wife to her dead husband in the woods, He saw a women digging and burying them. This women turned out be the lover of the husband. The husband was cheating on his wife with her, But the kid has no memory of that and he was in shock when he found out. Later he confessed that he isn’t the dead husband like he claimed.
Imo, I think he was really the dead husband, The kid is 10 years old and he told his mother I’m not your son anymore, He continued to show that he know people he never meet before, He didn’t remember everyone or their names but he would call their names subconsciously. He let go of his wife because he learned about his cheating and that my friends in genuine love.