Discussion Mafia Awards

[Holt]

So @Crescent Jinx and @GrySun brought up the idea of Mafia Awards. Considering how active this section is, and the history, it's indeed a good idea.

This thread is to serve as a brainstorming place for potential Mafia Awards. We'll appreciate suggestions for categories and awards you'd like to see.

Current Suggestions

• Best Avatar Sets
• Best Theme
• Best Game Current Year
• Best Game Overall
• Most Troll Host
• Best Host
• Best Surprise Moment
• Worse Moment
• Most Disappointing Game
• Most Aggressive Player
• Best Role
• Most Improved Player
• Most Afk player (yea, idc what they say)
• Best Council Member that actually does stuff
• Most Improved MG Player
• Best Mechanics
• Most Friendly Player
• Best Newbie Player
• Best Returning Player
• Saltiest Player
• Best Game Moment
• Best Town Player
• Best Mafia Player
• Best Third Party Player
• Most Memorable Mafia Victory
• Most Memorable Town Victory
• Most Polyvalent Player (for someone who has the best balance as a player whether he is Town, Mafia or TP)
• Best New Role
• Best Role Creator.
• Best Role Use
• Best Team

 

[Crescent Jinx]

1. Best Avatars
2. Best Theme
3. Best Game Current Year
4. Best Game Overall
5. Most Troll Host
6. Best Host
7. Best Surprise Moment
8. Worse Moment
9. Most Disappointing Game
10. Most Aggressive Player
11. Best Role
12. Most Improved Player
13. Most Afk player (yea, idc what they say)
14. Best Council Member that actually does stuff

 

[Farfalla]

Some categories suggested in the Soulpad:

• Best Game of the Year
• Most Improved MG Player
• Best Avatar Sets
• Best Theme
• Best Mechanics
• Most Friendly Player
• Most Aggressive Player
• Best Newbie Player
• Best Returning Player
• Saltiest Player
• Best Host of the Year
• Most Trolling Host
• Best Game Moment
• Best Town Player
• Best Mafia Player
• Best Third Party Player
• Most Memorable Mafia Victory
• Most Memorable Town Victory

 

[GrySun]

I really don‘t think it needs many categories. Best Town Player and Best Mafia Player are the core, and Best Game of the year. Not a fan of most other categories.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Also apologies if I destroy MH too much. I really try my best to be a good global mod, but I simply suck.

Its ok Kev

 

[Crescent Jinx]

I really don‘t think it needs many categories. Best Town Player and Best Mafia Player are the core, and Best Game of the year. Not a fan of most other categories.

Then what kind of event is it? That’s only 3 awards.

 

[Farfalla]

I really don‘t think it needs many categories. Best Town Player and Best Mafia Player are the core, and Best Game of the year. Not a fan of most other categories.

No

 

[GrySun]

Then what kind of event is it? That’s only 3 awards.

No

This is why we can't have nice things.

 

[Erinyes]

Seriously a Mafia Award, thts awesome !!

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

its gonna be either awesome or some salt parade

 

[Copy Panda]

Saltiest player sounds funny but negative awards seems kind of pointless

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2020 ---

Spicy destruction of the mh threads confirmed

 

[Lady pompom]

How about: 1-most memorable mafia win

2-most memorable town win?

 

[Demonspeed]

I think several are not needed like Saltiest, Friendliest, Aggressive, Troll, Disappointing, AFK. From my POV, the awards should reward good plays etc. Saltiness and Friendliness aren't really skills, and you can be aggressive without being good.

Also I think something like Most Polyvalent Player could be added. For someone who has the best balance as a player wether he is Town, Mafia or TP. Maybe something like Best New Role, Best Role Creator.

Maybe Best Role Use? Though it might overlap with Best Moment. Also Best Team?

 

[Holt]

I'm also against negative categories including those that might reward 'bad' play (like afk).
Best role use doesn't necessarily overlap with the best moment. The latter is more about an instance, the former will consider the general usage all game (or while the player was alive).

For "overall", I'm not particularly big on it. If this becomes an annual event, "overall" seems imo unnecessary

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2020 ---

Seriously a Mafia Award, thts awesome !!

Magi edited that in, I never wrote that lol XD

 

[Demonspeed]

Could be changed to Player of the Year maybe?

 

[Holt]

Newcomer/Returning players seem like good suggestions too, but both look like categories that can potentially die out or won't have many eligible nominations. Both will need time restrictions and we might end up having few to none participants there.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2020 ---

Could be changed to Player of the Year maybe?

On a game basis or overall performance throughout the yea?

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Most WTF moment?

 

[Demonspeed]

Newcomer/Returning players seem like good suggestions too, but both look like categories that can potentially die out or won't have many eligible nominations. Both will need time restrictions and we might end up having few to none participants there.

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2020 ---

On a game basis or overall performance throughout the yea?

The latter.

 

[Erinyes]

I'm also against negative categories including those that might reward 'bad' play (like afk).
Best role use doesn't necessarily overlap with the best moment. The latter is more about an instance, the former will consider the general usage all game (or while the player was alive).

For "overall", I'm not particularly big on it. If this becomes an annual event, "overall" seems imo unnecessary

--- Double Post Merged, Apr 17, 2020, Original Post Date: Apr 17, 2020 ---

Magi edited that in, I never wrote that lol XD

Oops my bad i didnt know , havent even realized it was edited, sorry ! (edit, just edited my post, sorry again i should be more attentive)


So Magi can edit a message from a blue, omoshiroi, im in awe @Purity of Magi

so this is confimed : Magi> blue ! she will definiitely take over the forum someday !

 

[Farfalla]

Magi edited that in, I never wrote that lol XD

Now he's pointing fingers at @Purity of Magi ....... Rly, Holtie, rly...