- Joined
- Feb 15, 2013
- Messages
- 2,142
- Reaction score
- 1,307
- Gender
- Hidden
- Country
This theory isn't my own and I am not really convinced of it as things are right now. It comes from the Tim's Tail blog. Just to be clear, the theory here is not that Nea wasn't a Noah! The theory is that the Noah memory in Allen is a separate entity from the "Nea" who just woke up in chapters 214-215. The blogger doesn't really explain how this can be (and sort of contradicts him/herself in a way), to be honest, but still, I find the theory interesting for a couple of reasons. So although I'm not convinced myself, I thought it would be fun to share it and see what people think until we have more chapters to shed light on this stuff. Specifically, what would make this theory work/not work with the main story, in your opinion?
The main blogger's main basis for saying this appears to be a comparison of Nea's behaviour in 214-215 to other Noahs, whose memories work differently from his, as well as the 14th's brief appearances (182, 198, etc.).
Allen's body was on the verge of total Noahfication and he fell into a lethargic state. At the time it seemed like he finally regained consciousness, it was actually the long-sleeping Nea who finally opened his eyes. Taking in Nea's conduct after his revival in a new body for the first time in 35 years, he's surprised by Allen's white hair and facial scar. He knows nothing about himself currently, or his surroundings up until now. So who was it that scolded Allen and grabbed his hand (59), said his name is 'Nea' (198), surfaced to greet the Millennium Earl (182), and declared war against him too (189)?
When a Noah Reincarnates
(1) Noah don't keep their previous hosts' memories
With the exception of Wisely who has a special ability (187), all the Noahs who were killed by the 14th don't know his face. Also, Dezaiasu (Sheril Kamelot) in chapter 202 wants information on the 14th from the captured Bookman.
(2) The Noah do keep their newest host's memories
Skinn Bolic (96) remembers he worked at the shipyard and orders the father to murder everyone.
The case of Nea emerging from "Allen" contradicts both of these major principles. Because of this, I'm led to believe (lol) "Nea ≠ 14th Noah Memory."
From ティムのしっぽ:
As for the art above (volume on top; magazine below), attention is drawn to a change in facial expressions that the blogger finds indicate more of a sense of confusion (and less "light" in the eyes). Especially if you take it as following how he looks when he's first waking up in bed (see below). In my opinion, Allen's hair got curvier in the revised version. Its overall shape looks more like Nea's now, imo (not that that means anything on its own).
Obviously, points refuting this theory would include that the 14th is supposed to be a special Noah, &/or that perhaps because Allen somehow volunteered himself, things are different. (I'd also thought it was significant that the 14th specifically introduces himself as "Nea" in chapter 198, but were this theory to be true, there are a lot of ways that could be explained.) Thoughts?
The main blogger's main basis for saying this appears to be a comparison of Nea's behaviour in 214-215 to other Noahs, whose memories work differently from his, as well as the 14th's brief appearances (182, 198, etc.).
体のノア化が極限まで進み昏睡状態に陥ったアレンでしたが、
ようやく意識を取り戻したと見えた時 実際に目を覚ましたのは彼の中にずっと眠っていたネアの方でした。
これが、新しい体で復活したネアの 35年ぶり初の目覚めだったことは、その後の言動からも見て取れます。
(自分=“アレン”の白髪や顔の傷を見て驚いている。これまで自身や彼の周囲で起きていた事を何も知らない)
では、これまでアレンの夢の中で彼に話しかけ腕を掴んだり(第59夜)自分を「ネア」だと名乗ったり(第198夜)、現実に浮上してきて千年伯爵に目覚めの挨拶(第182夜)や宣戦布告(第189夜)をしていたのは誰※なんでしょうか。
(※ 私はネアより先に出てきた“14番目ノアメモリー”単独の意志表示であった、としてい ます)
ノアメモリーが転生した場合。
(1) 先代の宿主の記憶は持たない
(第187夜⇒特殊能力のワイズリー以外、転生したノア達は先代を殺した犯人の14番目の顔も知らない)
(第202夜⇒デザイアス(シェリル・キャメロット)は拉致したブックマンから生前の14番目情報を聞き出そうとする)
(2) 新しい宿主の記憶は、覚醒前のものも保持している
(第96夜⇒スキン・ボリックは覚醒前に自分が働いていた造船所の事を覚えていて神父に皆殺しを命じる)
この二大原則があったはずですが、“アレン”から出てきたネアの場合はこのどちらとも矛盾しています。
ここから導き出される結論は(笑) “ネア≠14番目メモリー” だと思うんですが。
(1) Noah don't keep their previous hosts' memories
With the exception of Wisely who has a special ability (187), all the Noahs who were killed by the 14th don't know his face. Also, Dezaiasu (Sheril Kamelot) in chapter 202 wants information on the 14th from the captured Bookman.
(2) The Noah do keep their newest host's memories
Skinn Bolic (96) remembers he worked at the shipyard and orders the father to murder everyone.
The case of Nea emerging from "Allen" contradicts both of these major principles. Because of this, I'm led to believe (lol) "Nea ≠ 14th Noah Memory."
As for the art above (volume on top; magazine below), attention is drawn to a change in facial expressions that the blogger finds indicate more of a sense of confusion (and less "light" in the eyes). Especially if you take it as following how he looks when he's first waking up in bed (see below). In my opinion, Allen's hair got curvier in the revised version. Its overall shape looks more like Nea's now, imo (not that that means anything on its own).
Obviously, points refuting this theory would include that the 14th is supposed to be a special Noah, &/or that perhaps because Allen somehow volunteered himself, things are different. (I'd also thought it was significant that the 14th specifically introduces himself as "Nea" in chapter 198, but were this theory to be true, there are a lot of ways that could be explained.) Thoughts?
Last edited: