In my breakdown, I'll evaluate each players efforts (regardless of good, bad, or ugly) and provide some constructive criticism in hopes that they can take something away from it~
Before the specific rundown, I think something from the town side of things was the tremendous lack of pressure on those who you were suspicious of with two scums getting the win without even claiming. Genuinely unthinkable that this could've happened and a timely reminder to all to lock in more, chase facts and keep people honest on critical information like hints, claims and actions because there weren't enough direct questions being asked and not enough pressure being applied in later days.
______________________
Sakura || Prosecutor - I dug the boots in quite a bit via PM during the game after your death, but I think the gameplay criticisms should be reiterated in hopes you'll listen, learn, and grow from criticisms that have been present in this game and previous ones. As displayed in your PMs when you were alive and through how you played, there appeared to be a major lack of thought behind your actions, leading you to decide to pull the trigger on Prosecutor far too early from a game assessment. The lack of thought behind how best to use your role as well as lack of engagement before you made your decision echo criticism others have had on your play in recent games and serve as a reminder that you need to get out of your own player bubble and observe the landscape of the game before making any hasty calls, and doubly so when you have a role as important to the construction of the game as Prosecutor was here. It might be harsh to say your usage of it soured the game, but I think it's the politest way to say you need to take some time to reflect and evaluate how you make decisions in-game as well as how you play it.
Raven || Prostitute // Super Mason - I genuinely think you have a great feel for the game based on your limited outings and could grow to become a really good player, but you got in your own way this game by being too headstrong and unwilling to take a step back, listen and evaluate a bit more critically in moments like when Lambu subbed in. Take more time to analyse and regardless of suspicions, allow yourself the chance to listen to other players to be better informed of your decision making in future games. Aside from that, the tone of some of your posts come across as very pointed/heated, so I think being less forceful/blunt would also be constructive to the game not having a 'harsh' tone/vibe to it.
Demonspeed || Detective - A solid game with good deduction and some smart targeting to boot. Could potentially have pushed others further to develop the game by having others reveal, but a good game nonetheless with a few heated interactions I'd trust you wouldn't repeat in the future.
GB || Sane Apprentice - Given your unfortunate circumstances with being repeatedly blocked, it was hard for you to have an impact. It mightn't be in your style to do so, but potentially taking the reigns and being more assertive in pursuing answers from others could have been a step forward in getting town closer to a victory in light of yourself being crippled.
Misha || Naive Doctor - A victim of D1, and thus not a lot of chance to make an impact on the game. It would've been nice to see you join the deadpad and stay connected to the game that way, but hopefully next time you get a longer crack at it to play and also develop in-game skills and logic.
Asako || Naive Detective - Another early-game victim, you showed some activity early which was welcomed to see plus you had one of the nicer avatars of the game. Your N1 target given what had happened was also sound so all in all you showed some good signs of solid evaluation.
Lambu || Sane Doctor - My goodness, you didn't have a lot of time to cook but in the time you did have you quickly became the bastion of town with the best analysis, great targeting, and sound arguments that could've been game-winning if not for the incredibly poor mislynch. Always a pleasure to see this bird in full flight, and an example of the quality players should aspire to. Alongside Demon, I'd say you two were the highlights of town.
Erinyes || Necromancer - A shorter stay than you would've liked but a solid one. I think you could get on the front foot a bit more and push/pursue those you suspect a bit more to try and tease more out of them than you might have otherwise gotten. List or no list, a decent effort.
Kakoha || Paranoid Detective - What a first game! You had a really solid outing and showed some good reasoning and intuition that with time will have you grow into a great player if you stick around. You probably let yourself get led on a bit too much by others and could be a bit stronger in pushing those you suspect to get more out of them.
Jinx || Paranoid Spy // Super Mason - A decent outing but you left more to be desired from your decision making and reads. While Raven wasn't the worst to use Super Mason on, it might have been more beneficial to target another player like Demon who, at least in the limited time he'd of still been around, perhaps been able to build a stronger list of suspects to then chase around in the day. I also think you could've been a bit more pushy on those you suspected, and used your influence in the Super Mason chat to not have GB blocked that 3rd time
DD || Mafia Escort - My biggest criticism is what led to your downfall: your hint. You were very wishy-washy by only saying you had "a night role", and that was basically the act of saying 'hey guys look at me I'm suspicious'. Should've been lynched Day 1 if not for the Prosecutor blunder, but apart from instantly getting the heat on you like that you were alright.
Brando || Mafia Detective - I'm genuinely shocked at how you managed to skate by without claiming which is a mark against Town as a whole. I think your play started strong but when you pulled back Day 2, it looked a bit odd and that could've gotten you into more strife. Ultimately it didn't, but I better see a claim next game or I'm confiscating your next crate of Great Northerns
Holt || Mafia Strongman - Another who made it through without claiming which was a real shock. I think you did a good job of being the head of the serpent for your team so to speak, and managed to blend in well enough to guide your team to victory so good effort.
Marmalade || Hider // Lover - A great effort to blend in as third party and ended up very close to victory. I think you being active made people question you a bit more given how sparse you typically are, but it was a welcome sight to see you being a bit more proactive where time allowed.
Belserion || Mafia Pirate // Lover - An unfortunate slip brought about what had been a great campaign to an unsuccessful end for yourself and your faction. I think it would be good to see you be more assertive and active in games as a step forward as you're often very sparse and inactive in games discussion-wise which while a generally successful strat mightn't work forever. One last factor I'd suggest is the use of alarms ahead of the end of phases so you can place crucial votelocks next time.
Shad || Sane Doctor - This might come off as harsh but I'm extremely disappointed in your behaviour and eventual request to be hostkilled which felt like the worst black mark on this game from a couple of questionable/disappointing moments. Everyone is held to the same standard in games but you acted out and forced your way out of a game you were expected to be committed to unless something genuine arose and would stop you from being able to meet the minimum requirements. Given your DMs to my co-host you could've taken his advice and had a break and then been a lot more reasonable as you had shown in PM analysis but you didn't which I find to be a slap in the face. This goes without mentioning, but your behaviour towards me and especially my co-host after being rightfully put in the hall of shame was also unacceptable and like a toddler throwing a tantrum- you're a grown man so act like it, even if your circumstances are unrelenting. People deserve to be treated with respect even if you're having difficulties with them or are frustrated with them, but you spat in his face and treated him extremely poorly, and that sort of bollocks won't ever be tolerated.
_____________________________________________
On a final note, I don't know when I'll host again this year or if I will again any time soon as I should lock in with my academic studies this year, but it'd be remiss of me to finish off without taking the time to once again thank my co-host
@Copy Panda . You got me started with hosting with the Shokugeki game we did together, and then the Chainsam Pan game. I did a joint with Lambu, but then you and I ran it back for this one. Your insight, your passion, and your knowledge of the game are immeasurable and you're both a brilliant mind and a delight to get to consult and host with. I'm very thankful to call you a friend and I'm very glad that what might be a final joint for now got to return to where it all started with you being at the reigns with me. Thank you can't show my appreciation enough, but you're vitally important to this community and we're all lucky to have you here.
Also, thank you again to
@Marmalade for her diligent work with the avatars. I really liked the artistic direction you took with them and I think they turned out wonderful.