I'm as honest as it gets. I joked about being vanilla. It fell flat. I dropped a hint. It wasn't picked up.
And hey, no need for insults. That's just uncalled for. Forgive me, I'm rusty. Haven't played for years by now.
Seems no one remembers my epic lover play anymore.
That strikes me as weird to feel the need to put a placeholder after you having previous activity and then to have it be someone who was out of the general voting sphere thus far. You wouldn't happen to be red would you Erin?
When she was active most of her posts were just fluff aside from a couple of hints, one a bit useless at that. Throw in the strange timing of a 'placeholder' vote when the posts directly above her which she'd see when writing her post had votes, she'd be aware that there's at least a bit more at play.
So, while you're correct that at the time she was active it was votes for Shad and myself, to suddenly come along and throw a random vote out there has me raising an eyebrow. Not a guarantee she'll be back by the end of the phase from the sounds of it too so it's a convenient safe vote if town ended up mislynching a townie. And yes, it is day 1, but still a bit questionable imo.
About Xad claim about being safe on crowd, the way he worded/phrased it didn’t sound sus to me. More like he was taking a shot at other players claiming vanilla. And so far I am more sus to those claiming vanilla super early.
It’s day 1 so not much to go with
i like kat, asako and evil, their anti-xad attitude (xaditude if u will) i think is pro-town
xad is sus for his silly vanilla play, Sam kinda iffy over his weird questioning of Kat + backpedaling against Xad vote is kind of tryhard and also keeping himself safe sort of? shad also afk but he said he was gonna sleep at 8am? guess mans had a long night
maybe ill end up switching to sam or sth, dont have opinions on the rest yet
Sam, it kind of feels like you’re trying a little bit too hard to make others people feel as suspicious today. I don’t know if I’m right about this, but it feels off to me.
I don’t see anything wrong with Erin’s posts so far at all (and also, the Kat-meow thing makes this feeling stronger for me).
so for now: !votekill Sam.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
That doesn’t clear my suspicions on Xadyu btw, he’s still kinda weird in my eyes - hasn’t played in a long time so maybe he’s rusty
About Xad claim about being safe on crowd, the way he worded/phrased it didn’t sound sus to me. More like he was taking a shot at other players claiming vanilla. And so far I am more sus to those claiming vanilla super early.
It’s day 1 so not much to go with
i like kat, asako and evil, their anti-xad attitude (xaditude if u will) i think is pro-town
xad is sus for his silly vanilla play, Sam kinda iffy over his weird questioning of Kat + backpedaling against Xad vote is kind of tryhard and also keeping himself safe sort of? shad also afk but he said he was gonna sleep at 8am? guess mans had a long night
maybe ill end up switching to sam or sth, dont have opinions on the rest yet
Around 7 hours to go, maybe gonna be extended by an hour or 2 if I oversleep since I still gotta take care of some stressful matters.
Meanwhile 6 people's votes still missing, some have even yet to post I believe, so yeah that's a thing. Will tag any low post/vote people at last hour, mainly for keeping track.
Remember that you have time until the end of the Day to pick your path or change the path you picked.
i like kat, asako and evil, their anti-xad attitude (xaditude if u will) i think is pro-town
xad is sus for his silly vanilla play, Sam kinda iffy over his weird questioning of Kat + backpedaling against Xad vote is kind of tryhard and also keeping himself safe sort of? shad also afk but he said he was gonna sleep at 8am? guess mans had a long night
maybe ill end up switching to sam or sth, dont have opinions on the rest yet
Sam, it kind of feels like you’re trying a little bit too hard to make others people feel as suspicious today. I don’t know if I’m right about this, but it feels off to me.
I don’t see anything wrong with Erin’s posts so far at all (and also, the Kat-meow thing makes this feeling stronger for me).
so for now: !votekill Sam.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
That doesn’t clear my suspicions on Xadyu btw, he’s still kinda weird in my eyes - hasn’t played in a long time so maybe he’s rusty
I can see how that comes across but I'm just trying to probe for information and reactions as it's all I can do until I eventually get some progress via the paths and hopefully get a solid role to then contribute in other ways
- Shad claims vanilla
- Sam says maybe we are all vanilla
- Xadyu joins the vanilla train.
All vanilla claims stop.
I challenged Sam's claim because I don't think this was a game with only vanillas.
In a normal game 2 vanillas is possible, 3 I don't think I've ever seen it, especially not in such a small game.
Xadyu lied, joked, was sarcastic, doing all the thing a town shoudn't.
Sam could have been a mafia believing the setup to be majority vanilla.
Xadyu and Sam voting each other means this will likely end with one of them lynched.
I would support sam in this case, since if Xadyu flips town, I can blame him for being rusty ^^
Let see, getting a coffee and will rejoin the discussion in 1h
I like vanilla on my ice cream but this much vanilla on a mafia game is getting on my nerves.
And due to the mechanics, it will be super convininent for mafias to claim later. So, people wo did not claim anything so far including me, should be sus too.
Therefore, I will claim that, I'm no vanilla. With the posts so far, Evil looks town to me....but not much info about others to form an opinion.
I will go to sleep shortly and might miss rest of the day. So, I votekill Shad
And due to the mechanics, it will be super convininent for mafias to claim later. So, people wo did not claim anything so far including me, should be sus too.
You think people that didn't claim are sus but then vote the person that claimed in literally the first post, very inconsistent.
--- Double Post Merged, , Original Post Date: ---
I don't think the mechanic makes it easier to claim, you still need to claim a role, the mechanic can add a bit of confusion claim wise, with extra temp roles or secondaries, that may be faked it necessary by mafia.
So this was supposed to be a joke? I can sort of see the sarcastic nature of it, but it can also appear like a legit claim. I also haven't really picked up a hint in your other posts unless it was to do with one of your 'complaints' or the mother-in-law thing
About Xad claim about being safe on crowd, the way he worded/phrased it didn’t sound sus to me. More like he was taking a shot at other players claiming vanilla. And so far I am more sus to those claiming vanilla super early.
It’s day 1 so not much to go with
The 3 vanilla claims happened within the first 12 posts if I am not mistaken. So by susing super early vanilla claims, do you mean Shad's first post or Sam's? Out of the 3 of them, Xadyu claimed it last (waited like 10 posts to join Shad and Sam) - is that not suspicious to you then?
You don't even bother to point to the post in question? That's the bare minimum you could do to help us.
Votekill Xadyu
The 3 vanilla claims happened within the first 12 posts if I am not mistaken. So by susing super early vanilla claims, do you mean Shad's first post or Sam's? Out of the 3 of them, Xadyu claimed it last (waited like 10 posts to join Shad and Sam) - is that not suspicious to you then?
There's no fun to this game if everyone just spits everything out. I've always played like this. I like hinting, I dislike flat out telling.
Woj is the only one that did understand I was joking, it seems.. I mean, I'm rusty, but if I was a mafia, that would've been a fucking dead-ass mistake. I'm not that rusty.
There's been an update to our forum rules to broaden crediting/sourcing to all series news/announcement, etc. Please read HERE
Oscars Contest 2023 is LIVE! Click HERE for a chance to win your Oscar!
It's back! MH presents a celebration of manga/anime culture; Mangahelpers Awards 2022 is NOW LIVE!
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
