Info Mafia Game Hall Of Shame

[Evil3ye]

HALL OF SHAME:

Host Kill Log.

• Hystzen was disqualified for revealing game sensitive information in Game 4.
• kakashi919 was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 6.
• Channy was hostkilled for in activity in Game 6.
• yukilove21 was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 7.
• xAznSinnage was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 7.
• BBB Banana was hostkilled for breaking rules in Game 7.
• digitaldude was disqualified for revealing game sensitive information in Game 8.
• jorped was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 10.
• Xadyu was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 10.
• Hystzen was disqualified for revealing game sensitive information in Game 10.
• Imperium was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 15.
• Baka Taichou was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 16.
• kdowns was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 17.
• Adorien was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 17.
• googlez_kun was hostkilled for inactivity in Game 18.
• wizzard was hostkilled for breaking rules in Game 18.
• Tatasugoi was hostkilled for revealing game sensitive information in Game 19.
• xi0 was hostkilled for receiving game sensivitve information in Game 19.
• kdowns is not allowed to participate in Game 21, because of inactivity in Game 20.
• Charlie is not allowed to participate in Game 21, because of inactivity in Game 20.
• kkck is not allowed to participate in Game 22, because of inactivity in Game 21.
• Baka Taichou is not allowed to participate in Game 22, for revealing game sensitive information in Game 21, while being dead.
• Macaco is not allowed to participate in Game 23, because of inactivity in Game 22.
• Xadyu is not allowed to participate in Game 23, because of inactivity in Game 22.
• Kazu-Sama is not allowed to participate in Game 23, because of inactivity in Game 22.
• BBB Banana is not allowed to participate in Game 23, because of inactivity in Game 22.
• Baka Taichou is not allowed to participate in Game 24 & 25, because of inactivity in Game 23.
• thornofcarrion is not allowed to participate in Game 25, because of inactivity in Game 24.
• FaustXIII is not allowed to participate in Game 26, because of inactivity in Game 25.
• Hakuteiken is not allowed to participate in Game 26, because he told everyone about the remaining mafia in Game 25.
• kdowns is not allowed to participate in Games 27, 28, 29 & 30, because of inactivity in Game 26.
• Kat is not allowed to participate in Game 27, because of inactivity in Game 26.
• lawlett-kun is not allowed to participte in Game 28 because he posted the PM from the host about his role in Game 27 and kept posting in the game thread when he's already disqualified.
• FaustXIII is not allowed to participate in Game 29, 30 & 31, because of inactivity in Game 28.
• Ustegius is not allowed to participate in Game 29, because of inactivity in Game 28.
• BBB Banana is not allowed to participate in Game 29, 30 & 31, because of inactivity in Game 28.
• shinsengumi is not allowed to participate in Game 29 because of inactivity in Game 28.
• Xerous is not allowed to participate in Game 29 because of inactivity in Game 28.
• digitaldude is not allowed to participate in Game 30, because of inactivity in Game 29.
• Adorien is not allowed to participate in Game 32, because of her retirement in Game 31.
• matzik1212 is not allowed to participate in Game 33, because of inactivity in Game 32.
• Imperium is not allowed to participate in Game 33, because of his retirement in Game 32.
• nanaDmari is not allowed to participate in Games 35, because of inactivity in Game 34.
• BBB Banana is banned until further notice, because of inactivity in Game 35.
• TheBoss is not allowed to participate in Game 39, because of inactivity in Game 38.
• Xadyu is not allowed to participate in Game 40, 41 & 42, because of inactivity in Game 39.
• Ustegius is not allowed to participate in Game 40, 41 & 42, because of his cutting short in Game 39.
• Zeltrax is not allowed to participate in Game 41, because of inactivity in Game 40.
• Nico Brown is not allowed to participate in Game 41, because of inactivity in Game 40.
• Nico Brown is not allowed to participate in Game 43, 44 & 45 because of inactivity in Game 42.
• Zasz is not allowed to participate in Game 44 because of inactivity in Game 43.
• lawlett-kun is not allowed to participte in Game 48, 49 & 50, for posting fake host PMs in Game 47.
• GrySun is not allowed to participte in Game 48 for posting host PMs in Game 47.
• Naomi is not allowed to participate in Games 48, because of inactivity in Game 47.
• YumaKuga is not allowed to participate in Game 49, because of Inactivity in Game 48.
• Philia is not allowed to participate in Game 50, because of Inactivity in Game 49.
• Xadyu is banned until further notice, because of inactivity in Game 49.
• SheepyTurtle is not allowed to participate in Game 52, because of inactivity in Game 51.
• SugarKitty is not allowed to participate in Game 52, because of inactivity in Game 51.
• Utsune is not allowed to participate in Game 52, because of inactivity in Game 51.
• xnut is not allowed to participate in Game 57, because of inactivity in Game 56.
• Mazino is not allowed to participate in Game 58, because of inactivity in Game 57.
• Qixus is not allowed to participate in Game 58, because of inactivity in Game 57.
• xnut is not allowed to participate in Game 59 & 60 because of inactivity in Game 58.
• Kiki is not allowed to participate in Game 59, because of inactivity in Game 58.
• Kiki is not allowed to participate in Game 60 & 61 because of inactivity in Game 59.
• Kato756 is not allowed to participate in Game 60, because of inactivity in Game 59.
• Demonspeed is not allowed to participate in Game 61 for posting host PMs in Game 60.
• Erinyes is not allowed to participate in Game 61 for posting host PMs in Game 60.
• Xadyu is unbanned as of Game 61.
• BluePegasus is not allowed to participate in Game 62, because of inactivity in Game 61.
• Mononoke is not allowed to participate in Game 62, because of inactivity in Game 61.
• kira is not allowed to participate in Game 62, because of inactivity in Game 61.
• Elusia is not allowed to participate in Game 65, because of inactivity in Game 64.
• Commanderaxe is not allowed to participate in Game 68, because of inactivity in Game 67.
• kkck is not allowed to participate in Game 68, 69 & 70, because of inactivity in Game 67.
• Kato756 is not allowed to participate in Game 71, 72 & 73, because of inactivity in Game 70.
• Lambu is not allowed to participate in Game 74, because of inactivity in Game 73.
• Kiki is not allowed to participate in Game 76, 77 & 78, because of inactivity in Game 75.
• Arjuna is not allowed to participate in Game 77, because of inactivity in Game 76.
• Brandish is not allowed to participte in Game 79 for posting host PMs in Game 78.
• Buffynut is not allowed to participate in Game 80, because of inactivity in Game 79.
• Kato756 is banned until further notice, because of inactivity in Game 80.
• Kato756 is banned until game 91, because of inactivity in Game 80.
• Spirit is not allowed to participate in Game 82, because of inactivity in Game 81.
• gnut is not allowed to participate in Game 82, because of inactivity in Game 81.
• revo retired from Game 81.
• Copy Panda is not allowed to participate in Game 86 for deleting a post in Game 85.
• Raven is not allowed to participate in Game 86 for revealing game sensitive information in Game 85, while dead.
• Crescent Jinx is not allowed to participate in Game 88 for posting host PMs in Game 87.
• Baka Taichou is not allowed to participate in Game 88, 89 and 90 for posting host PMs in Game 87.
• BBB Banana is unbanned as of Game 88.
• gnut is not allowed to participate in Game 92, 93 and 94, because of inactivity in Game 91.
• Asako retired from Game 93.
• Demonspeed retired from Game 93.
• Crescent Jinx is not allowed to participate in Games 103, 104 and 105, due to playing against her win-con in Game 102.
• AwkwardMisha retired from Game 102.
• Erinyes is not allowed to participate in Game 103, due to playing against her win-con in Game 102.
• Demonspeed is not allowed to participate in Game 105, due to sharing sensitive PM content in Game 104.
• Sky retired from Game 106.
• gnut retired from Game 106.
• Baka Taichou retired from Game 108.
• Kato756 is not allowed to participate in Game 109, because of inactivity in Game 108.
• Kat retired from Game 110.
• Shad is not allowed to participate in Game 114, for faking the use of a day ability in game 113.
• boolbool is not allowed to participate in Game 115, because of inactivity in Game 114.
• desin24 is not allowed to participate in Game 116 for inactivity in Game 115.
• Shad is not allowed to participate in Games 120, 121 & 122, for being Host Killed in game 119.

Spoiler: General Information

General Infraction Treatment

-All infractions (meaning, a hostkill for being inactive, a player hostkilled for revealing sensitive PM information, etc) will have the same punishment.

-Players that are banned CANNOT host, co-host nor consult.

-If a player has been listed in the Hall of Shame before, the host of a game is allowed to NOT let the player join regardless if the player is currently banned or not (only to be used in extreme cases).

Players are still allowed to appeal their bans in the Hall of Shame.

Ban and forgiveness system

All players start at Stage 0.

Stage 0: you are unbanned.
Stage 1: you are banned one game.
Stage 2: you are banned three games.
Stage 3: you are banned ten games.
Stage 4: you are banned permanently.

If you're punished, you are moved up one (1) stage. To move back a stage, you have to PLAY ten (10) games without moving up a stage.

 

[Hardy]

I can accept this thread being a thing but we should also have a hall of fame then.

https://mangahelpers.com/forum/showthread.php/2994922-Mafia-Game-Hall-Of-Fame

It ain't hard to research Mr. Mod o/

 

[Tatasugoi]

"Tatasugoi was hostkilled for revealing game sensitive information in Game 19.
xi0 was hostkilled for receiving game sensivitve information in Game 19."

 

[xi0]

Oh god...well that was an unfortunate occurrence...

 

[GrySun]

And then game 48 was the best mafia game ever.

 

[GrySun]

Decided to update this when needed, starting with the hostkills of the last game.

--- Double Post Merged, Jan 9, 2018, Original Post Date: Dec 27, 2017 ---

Added the hostkills from last game.

 

[Arjuna]

@Demonspeed and @Erinyes not in the game.

The game loses half of it's splendour.

 

[Evil3ye]

HALL OF SHAME:

• Copy Panda is not allowed to participate in Game 86 for deleting a post in Game 85.
• Raven is not allowed to participate in Game 86 for revealing game sensitive information in Game 85, while dead.

Hey guys, @Raven @Copy Panda ,

just a short noticed to you, after internal discussion in aftermath of Game 85 we decided to bench you two for the next game.

In order to secure technically faultless games, we need to un-incentives potentially game harming behaviours to keep making enjoyable games for everyone. It is nothing personal, so I hope you understand.

You're of course welcome and encouraged to return to the game after next game.

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

sad times

 

[Raven]

Hey guys, @Raven @Copy Panda ,

just a short noticed to you, after internal discussion in aftermath of Game 85 we decided to bench you two for the next game.

In order to secure technically faultless games, we need to un-incentives potentially game harming behaviours to make enjoyable games for everyone. It is nothing personal, so I hope you understand.

You're of course welcome and encouraged to return to the after next game.

Since it’s evil eye who mentioned me, I will accept it

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

Would you not have accepted otherwise?

 

[Baka Taichou]

What? I donmt get it how were panda and raven harming behaviors?

 

[Lawl Po Bia]

What? I donmt get it how were panda and raven harming behaviors?

Raves basically revealed me and farf in her last post on d1

 

[Baka Taichou]

Raves basically revealed me and farf in her last post on d1

Rly? Did not notice

 

[Raven]

Rly? Did not notice

I did give hints not direct revealing, it had no impact on the game

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 31, 2020, Original Post Date: Oct 31, 2020 ---

If anything people actually were believing that lawt is the 2nd Jesus even after defending hard Farf who happened to be Mafia and she got killed because of her behavior and troll claiming and people almost killed desin instead of her despite that. I didn’t impact the game by any means. They simply lost because they played bad

 

[Hardy]

If it had a big consequence on the game or not should not be a factor. Similarly, panda's infraction had no impact in the game but it still shouldn't be allowed.

Nevertheless, it was clear that hints were dropped and they were picked up by some players (namely, @GrySun , at the very least) who did build cases on this information that they shouldn't have.

 

[Raven]

Ironically this grysun player who build up cases ended up voting desin instead of Farf, which heavily supports the fact that it had no impact on the game.

--- Double Post Merged, Oct 31, 2020, Original Post Date: Oct 31, 2020 ---

There is no rules stating that hints is not allowed, My hint can not be treated the same as revealing simply because it didn’t reveal anything.

 

[Evil3ye]

If it had a big enough impact the game would have ended irregularly instantly. The purpose of this is to prevent players "edging" with that kind of information.

But not only incriminating some, also the opposite. The discussion thread in between some phases was full of that.

Hope it helps understanding why we don't want that to happen again.

 

[Raven]

If it had a big enough impact the game would have ended irregularly instantly. The purpose of this is to prevent players "edging" with that kind of information.

Fair enough! But imo players edging out on this hint is really relying on a risky play, because as much as it could be helpful, it could as well be misleading. That’s why from my perspective it had no impact but I’m fine with your judgment regardless

 

[Evil3ye]

Fair enough! But imo players edging out on this hint is really relying on a risky play, because as much as it could be helpful, it could as well be misleading. That’s why from my perspective it had no impact but I’m fine with your judgment regardless

Hey Raven,

just couple of note from top of my head.

-I think it's good that you challenge it, it's best to be as transparent as possible here to try make you understand what the point of this is.
-if we process everything transparently it will increase acceptance and sensibilty to these kind of things, so I want to help out by some examples of what was not so great, and shouldn't be done in following games.
-Please don't take it as finger pointing.
-Now in spoiler couple of quotes from the discussion thread and my comments on the situation.

Spoiler

Grysun finally did a good thing with his last votelock.

poggers

This was done in reply to an active player breaking the tie and lynching a mafia. Can be strongly interpreted as confirming the active player as townie to other active non-mafia players. Even if it was just your opinion, sharing it while being dead with an active player is not allowed.

Good job @scav , you did good, I didn’t expect you to vote for the right person

Same as above.

c
You got the hint right tho, I meant farf. She was the only reason i didn't ruin the game for the mafia, You built right conclusions then you still voted desin.

So it cancels what you did.

Here you are confirming you left "hints" and discussing it with active players.

I just read your post and yeah you got it right, However, you still voted desin which is weird based on your previous doubts about farf

Same as above.

Also Farf voted me before ppl trainvoted me, She was the fourth vote and Brandish had more votes on him, Not gonna lie i felt sad about it but i managed to put myself in control since i like her. My brain was all about rage and revenge but i don't do to my girls any harm, You don't know how hard to fight yourself, I did the most hard thing which is going against myself.

Whatever, i find it more better to leave an ambiguous hint that is hard to figure, only people who knows me will unravel it and since panda knows me i guess it helped him ,however, there are a lot of girls that i love that plays the game so the hint wasn't directly at her.

This piece may active players draw more conclusions towards the mafia team.

These discussions are inappropriate and can be game ruining in some instances. The game hosts found it very intrusive and were compelled to lock thread to prevent even more game information to be leaked.

tl_dr bottom line on the Hall of Shame - dead players are dead and have to restrain themselves on the forum. It's not so much about the hints you left while being in the game (those were crypric enough, although some mafia members/hosts/viewers felt uncomfortable with it too).

 

[Raven]

Hey Raven,

just couple of note from top of my head.

-I think it's good that you challenge it, it's best to be as transparent as possible here to try make you understand what the point of this is.
-if we process everything transparently it will increase acceptance and sensibilty to these kind of things, so I want to help out by some examples of what was not so great, and shouldn't be done in following games.
-Please don't take it as finger pointing.
-Now in spoiler couple of quotes from the discussion thread and my comments on the situation.

Spoiler

This was done in reply to an active player breaking the tie and lynching a mafia. Can be strongly interpreted as confirming the active player as townie to other active non-mafia players. Even if it was just your opinion, sharing it while being dead with an active player is not allowed.


Same as above.

Here you are confirming you left "hints" and discussing it with active players.

Same as above.

This piece may active players draw more conclusions towards the mafia team.

These discussions are inappropriate and can be game ruining in some instances. The game hosts found it very intrusive and were compelled to lock thread to prevent even more game information to be leaked.

tl_dr bottom line on the Hall of Shame - dead players are dead and have to restrain themselves on the forum. It's not so much about the hints you left while being in the game (those were crypric enough, although some mafia members/hosts/viewers felt uncomfortable with it too).

Hello evil since you mentioned transparency, I want to be honest with you, Imo, you look into my posts as if it only benefits townies, as i mentioned before, It could be misleading.

So my question here is, Would you bother even if Mafia won? i just want an honest answer, Yes or no.


Again for the third time, I have no problem, but people here thinks i revealed info that lead to mafia losing which is not true, Again they lost because they played bad.